Ontario’s Access to Justice Crisis: Why ADR Matters More Than Ever
Toronto, September 30, 2026
Ontario is facing an access to justice crisis. Court backlogs, rising legal costs, chronic delay, procedural complexity, judicial vacancies and administrative bottlenecks have combined to create a system in which obtaining justice can be painfully slow and very expensive. For many litigants, the problem is no longer simply whether they have a strong case. The more immediate question is whether they can afford the time, enormous legal costs and uncertainty required to see their case through the court system until finality.

The crisis is particularly visible in Ontario civil and family litigation. Parties may wait months for motions, conferences and procedural steps, and years for a final trial. During that time, legal fees continue to accumulate, businesses remain distracted by unresolved disputes, families remain entrenched in conflict, and individuals seeking compensation or finality are left in prolonged uncertainty. Delay is not neutral. It can weaken claims, increase costs, place financial pressure on litigants and, in some cases, make a legally valid remedy practically inaccessible or worthless.
The adversarial system itself magnifies these pressures. Litigation requires pleadings, documentary production, examinations, motions, attendances, adjournments, expert evidence, trial preparation and potentially appeals. Each stage may be necessary in the appropriate case, but each stage also consumes time, money and eventually diminishes your quality of life. A dispute that began as a relatively straightforward disagreement can become buried beneath years of procedure, correspondence and escalating legal expenses. By the time judgment is finally obtained, even the successful party may reasonably ask whether the victory justified the cost.
Ontario’s criminal courts operate under constitutional time constraints arising from the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in R. v. Jordan. Civil litigants have no comparable constitutional guarantee that their disputes will be determined within a fixed period. Criminal proceedings understandably receive priority where liberty interests are engaged, but the practical consequence is that civil and family litigants are often left competing for already scarce judicial resources. In a system struggling with limited capacity, the waiting list itself becomes part of the litigation burden.
Technological modernization has not yet eliminated these difficulties. Ontario’s transition to digital court administration was intended to improve efficiency, but lawyers have reported considerable delays, technical problems and administrative friction associated with the new online systems. At the same time, changes requiring more in-person attendances in certain matters have raised concerns that clients will incur greater legal expense through travel, waiting time and lost productivity. The result is a justice system in which even procedural progress can carry a significant financial cost to the parties.
This is why Alternative Dispute Resolution should no longer be regarded as a secondary option to be considered only after litigation has failed. In the present environment, ADR should often be considered at the outset.
At DHS | ADR, we approach disputes from a different starting point. Rather than assuming that every disagreement must proceed through years of costly adversarial litigation, we examine whether negotiation, mediation, arbitration or neutral evaluation can provide a more proportionate, efficient and commercially sensible path to resolution. The objective is not to avoid the law, but to use the law intelligently, identify the real issues in dispute and determine whether those issues can be resolved without allowing procedure, delay and escalating legal costs to overwhelm the underlying problem.
At DHS | ADR , mediation allows parties to negotiate directly with the assistance of an independent neutral, without surrendering control of the outcome to a court. Arbitration provides a private adjudicative process where a binding decision is required, but where the parties wish to avoid the delay and procedural burden of conventional litigation. Neutral evaluation allows parties to obtain an independent assessment of the legal and evidentiary strengths and weaknesses of their positions before further costs are incurred. It also helps the parties towards advancing to a negotiated settlement rather than broadening the dispute, which can take months if not years to resolve.
The DHS | ADR advantage is not merely speed. It is control. Parties can structure the process around the real dispute, select the issues requiring determination, choose appropriate timelines, protect confidentiality and explore solutions that may never be available through a court judgment. In commercial disputes, that may preserve business relationships. In family matters, it may reduce hostility and allow parties to craft arrangements that better reflect their circumstances. In civil disputes, it may permit resolution before legal fees consume a substantial portion of the amount actually in issue.
Courts remain essential only when absolutely necessary. Some disputes require authoritative judicial determination, urgent remedies, public precedent or the enforcement powers of the state. But the existence of a court system does not mean that every disagreement should be litigated in a courtroom from beginning to end.
In the midst of an access to justice crisis, the question should no longer be simply, “Can we litigate this dispute?”
The better question is:
“Why are we litigating it if there is a faster, more proportionate and more effective way to resolve it?”
That is the philosophy behind DHS | ADR International Dispute Resolution Center. Negotiate first, litigate last.